Reese’s PB Chocolate Shake

Peanut butter + Chocolate = losing weight. Say what?! Doesn’t get any better than that! This is an S shake. Perfect for a snack or dessert!

Before Chocolate Sauce

Before Chocolate Sauce


After Chocolate Sauce

The Peanut Plus Protein Powder is just an incredible product. Gives that creamy peanut butter flavor plus protein without all the carbs and fat! Best price for this is at Vitacost. (New to Vitacost? Sign up here and get $10 off your first purchase! Plus they offer free shipping over $49!)

UPDATE: Looks like Vitacost stopped selling this amazing product. So sad! Best price is now on Amazon! Get it here! (affiliated link)

Don’t forget the Chocolate Sauce Recipe over here! Or leave it out if you’re in the mood for just rich peanut butter flavor!

Here is the THM Sweetener Conversion Chart for substitutes!

Reese's PB Chocolate Shake ~ S
Serves: 1
  • ½ Cup Unsweetened Almond Milk (plus maybe a little more depending on your blender)
  • 3-4 TBS Cottage Cheese (I use 1% or 2%)
  • ½ Scoop Swanson Vanilla Whey Protein Powder
  • 1-2 TBS Peanut Plus Protein Powder
  • 1-2 tsp. All Natural Peanut Butter
  • Pinch of Salt
  • 3 Packets Truvia
  • 8 Ice Cubes of Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk
  • Chocolate Sauce
  1. Put all ingredients in order listed into blender except ice cubes and chocolate sauce.
  2. Blend for a few minutes on low-medium.
  3. Add almond milk ice cubes and mix on medium for a little while.
  4. Pour into a glass and drizzle chocolate sauce (
If you're just in the mood for peanut butter and not chocolate, forgo the chocolate sauce for a mouth watering peanut butter shake!!




  1. Lori says:

    Good morning, Jen! I just found your website through THM FB page. Your recipes look amazing and I am excited about the product shopping recommendations since I am new to this way of cooking and struggling to acquire all the ingredients they suggest. This particular recipe looks wonderful, but I am having trouble identifying the Peanut Plus Protein Powder it calls for. I followed your link to Vitacost, but do not see a product like that listed. Help, please! What should I search for?

    • Jen says:

      Hi Lori! Thank you so much for bringing this to my attention! I’m so sorry about the link not working! I just updated the page and posted a new link. Amazon seems to be the place to purchase (go here)! And you can get free shipping over $35.00!

      I hope my recipes on Jen Saves will bring you and your family lots of joy and happiness!! I know when you’re just starting THM it can seem overwhelming, but I know you will get all the ingredients and pretty soon it will be a piece of THM cake! 😉 After a few months of doing THM, I created an Excel Doc for beginners. I need to go through and update it again, but hopefully it will be of some help to you!

Leave a Reply

Rate this recipe: